@Bloody Your latest map failed the automatic checks, so this channel has been moved to WAITING. Please fix the issues and resubmit.
Map Bugs found!
This map didn't pass the automatic checks. Press View Debug Output to see the details. Please address the issues, otherwise we're unable to release your map! If you're unable to resolve the bugs yourself, don't hesitate to ask!
@Bloody A new version was submitted, so the map has been moved back to TESTING.
i fix it
a speedrunner can't get the initial momentum because of a poorly made part right after the start. the unhook directly in front of the player is super inconvenient and will mess up speedruns, since the tee will have to go through the bottom. a bit further there's a swing through freeze in a tight space, which is also unpleasant for speedrunning, especially considering the map is meant to be novice, so it'll be pretty hard for a nobo to figure out how to do it
deep at the start is pretty tough for nobos
oh, thx, I fix it
do I understand correctly that it is necessary to make it so that it is not possible to jump over the entire frieze?
nah
it will be impossible to do the part then

this is how it should be, you have to hook Tii from the edge and run immediately to the right so that he reaches the antifreeze and then hook again and run to the wall to the left, without stopping
and then what is better to do, or to redo the part entirely?
redo the part imo
insanely unclear and faily for nobos
ok
then maybe I should add it instead, just a blow to the top to freeze?
unfreeze*
or make more hooktrough blocks
You don't have to use hooks to pull tii, you can hit him by grabbing onto the ceiling, this is a common practice.
I was thinking of making it possible to just jump into the wall (there are signs there)
hookthrough, give more space before the drop and make the zone where u need to land
Okay, I'll get on it.
i don't think fixing some of the things i pointed out earlier would help, there's a lot of design bugs, and overall the map is super generic. sometimes that's the whole point of a map. i don't wanna sound rude, but definitely not in this execution. every part is repetitive, same hooks and terrible balance. when it comes to drag parts, in most spots they end up being too narrow for both the player being dragged and the one dragging. nothing new, outdated parts
kinda tricky and faily parts for nobos
waiting for the tee to get unfreezed most of the time
i'd just suggest playing the game
maybe newest releases or something older
like some good og maps like tropica
I would like to make it better, about the design, what exactly do you mean? I thought everything was fine with him +- it will be what exactly is wrong with him
well, like I don't have much experience, so you pointed out the mistakes to me, I'll fix them as much as possible so that the map can be released, I've looked at recent releases and about the design, I think it's quite normal, I do not know what to improve or radically change in it.
and you also mention that something is difficult for beginners, but I don't think you're right, I invited not very skilled players to go through my map, and they didn't have much difficulty passing, except for the desk with anfre.
I think it's not novice
it's harder
why?
moderate 1 star?
i think it is novice, part They're pretty light
maybe 5 star novice??
invite nobos instead of skilled players
current version is pretty failable
honestly i don't think this is novice
a bit unclear as well ig
i wouldn’t strongly advise mapping novices when you’re new to mapping, mods or solos would be the best gametypes for a beginner to start with imo
I offered them to go through it and they coped with it, yes, difficulties arose, but not everything is so bad.
Well then it's moderate 1 star maybe?
its kinda unbalanced for now
stop pinging pls
you can copy the message link or off the notification
what exactly is unbalanced? I'll fix those 2 parts, what else?
not every feedback have a screen

lowk the whole map
what do you mean
ok so, i can't properly judge from the current version. imo it's pretty short, and as i mentioned earlier, quite repetitive. looking at the parts themselves, they're mostly narrow, especially some of the drag parts for players. the filler parts are pretty narrow too
there's no unfreeze in undeep
after, u have to immediately go up. also the passage before the drop is narrow
I’ll take everything you’ve said above into account and look into it, but what’s wrong with the last point?
I don't have time today.
remove the freeze above the drop, make the drop wider
okay
I'm sorry that ping


I don’t know what to do with the part you sent last.
I think what it is normal +-
I had a look at the map and i am sorry to inform you that your map wont get released on ddnet in its current state. The main issue is, that the map has very tight parts and don't support fast paced flowy gameplay. The parts kinda force you to slow down a lot while there are some unfair failing spots. I suggest to take a look at different newer novice maps that get played a lot to get an idea of what ddnet is currently looking for, if you want further information. You can also ask questions here. (The design is nice tho!) Some screens:
I hope this feedback is not too confusing. As i said, just ask if you want to learn more.
❌ Submission has been declined.
@Bloody Unfortunately, your map submission has been declined. Don't worry though, take a look at the feedback from our Testers, and consider playing our latest releases to gain more experience.
Can I fix this specific map and resubmit it later? Or should I just submit it again under the same name?
Well, the map is far from being released as Welf said. In my personal experience I would use this information and feedback to have in mind for next projects but fixing this map will take a lot longer. Again this is personal experience, feel free to keep working on this or other maps. If you decide to keep working on this one, yes, you can upload under the same name but make sure its reworked completly with the mentioned issues.
Thank you very much for your responses; I’m gradually learning and I think I’ll be able to make a good map one day 🙂
Im sure you can, good luck!!
You can technically do that, but i would also recommend you to learn what is fun first and then start a new map. Good luck

yo, ty
Okay, thanks guys. 🙏

